The excerpt from the passage that best states the authors’ claim is: “English factories, you might say, were built, run, and paid for by sugar.” This excerpt highlights the authors’ assertion that the English became wealthier due to their involvement in the sugar industry.
By connecting the growth of English factories directly to the production and trade of sugar, the authors emphasize the economic impact of sugar on England. This claim suggests that the sugar industry played a significant role in the country’s prosperity during that time.
Additionally, the authors imply that the wealth generated from sugar was a crucial factor in the development of English industries. Overall, the authors’ claim centers around the connection between sugar and the enrichment of the English.
Which Excerpt Illuminates The Author’s Claim
“The English were getting richer because Africans were being enslaved and forced to work on sugar plantations. ” This excerpt from the passage best states the author’s claim by highlighting the connection between the wealth of the English and the exploitation of Africans in the sugar industry.
Evaluation Of Key Excerpts
When evaluating a passage to determine which excerpt best states the author’s claim, it is important to carefully analyze the content and context of each option. In this case, the passage in question is “Sugar Changed the World,” and we are looking for the excerpt that most clearly conveys the author’s claim. Let’s examine each option:
- Option A: “The English were getting richer because Africans were being…”
- Option B: “Following the strand of sugar and slavery leads directly into the tumult of the Age of…”
- Option C: “English factories, you might say, were built, run, and paid for by sugar.”
- Option D: “It was some of the worst labor.”
Critical Analysis For The Truth
Upon critical analysis, option C stands out as the best choice for stating the author’s claim. It succinctly expresses the connection between sugar, English factories, and their financial benefits. This supports the overall claim of how sugar played a vital role in the economic prosperity of the English.
Option A touches upon the involvement of Africans, but it does not explicitly state the author’s claim regarding the English getting richer. Option B mentions the link between sugar, slavery, and the Age of… but lacks the direct focus on the author’s claim. Option D refers to the challenging nature of labor but does not provide the same level of clarity as option C.
Thus, it is clear that option C, “English factories, you might say, were built, run, and paid for by sugar,” best states the author’s claim in the passage.
Historical Context And Sugar’s Impact
The best excerpt from the passage that states the authors’ claim is: “English factories, you might say, were built, run, and paid for by sugar. ” This excerpt highlights the author’s claim that the English gained wealth and prosperity through the sugar industry.
Sugar’s Role In Societal Change
In the historical context of sugar’s impact, it becomes evident that sugar played a crucial role in shaping societies and bringing about significant changes. The narrative presented in the book highlights the transformative power of this sweet commodity, shedding light on its influence on various aspects of human existence.
One of the key observations made by the author is that the English society experienced a substantial increase in wealth and prosperity during the time when sugar became a dominant trade commodity. This is succinctly captured in the following excerpt from the passage, which best states the author’s claim:
“English factories, you might say, were built, run, and paid for by sugar.”
This statement vividly portrays the profound impact of sugar on the English economy, emphasizing how the trade in this commodity propelled their industrial growth and laid the foundation of their wealth accumulation. The author implies that sugar was not merely a product of consumption; it had far-reaching consequences that extended into all facets of society.
Moreover, the historical significance of sugar’s impact on societal change is further exemplified by the link between sugar and slavery. The passage underscores how the growth of the sugar industry fueled the demand for enslaved labor, provoking a tumultuous period known as the Age of Slavery. The following excerpt eloquently encapsulates this connection:
“Following the strand of sugar and slavery leads directly into the tumult of the Age of Slavery.”
With these words, the author unequivocally asserts the intertwined relationship between sugar production and the perpetuation of slavery, signifying how sugar not only influenced economic patterns but also had significant social and moral implications.
Furthermore, the arduous nature of work in the sugar industry is another dimension that the author emphasizes. The following excerpt sheds light on this aspect:
“Cleaning and weeding was…some of the worst labor.”
This quote accentuates the grueling and backbreaking labor involved in cultivating sugar, emphasizing the physical and mental toll it exacted on the workers. It underscores the harsh realities of the industry and further strengthens the author’s claim regarding sugar’s profound impact on the lives of those involved in its production.
All in all, the historical context presented in the passage provides a comprehensive understanding of sugar’s role in societal change. From driving economic growth to perpetuating slavery and subjecting individuals to toil, sugar emerges as a catalyst for transformations that reverberate through history.
Argument Dissection: Author’s Perspective
In this section, we will analyze the author’s perspective by dissecting their main claims and the supporting arguments and evidence they provide. By understanding the author’s perspective, we can gain insight into their overall claim and the message they are trying to convey.
Main Claims Made By The Author
- The English were getting richer because Africans were being enslaved and forced to work on sugar plantations.
- The connection between sugar and slavery played a significant role in shaping the Age of Exploration and the rise of England as a global power.
- English factories were built, run, and paid for by the profits generated from the sugar industry.
- The sugar industry led to the transformation of societies, economies, and environments, leaving a lasting impact on the world.
Supporting Arguments And Evidence
The author supports their claims by providing various excerpts from the passage:
| Excerpt | Author’s claim |
|---|---|
| “Following the strand of sugar and slavery leads directly into the tumult of the Age of Exploration, the Renaissance, and the rise of England as a world power.” | Connection between sugar, slavery, and the rise of England as a global power. |
| “English factories, you might say, were built, run, and paid for by sugar.” | English factories funded by sugar profits. |
| “For an African, whether you were sent to the Caribbean or South America, you were now part of the sugar machine.” | Impact of sugar industry on African slaves. |
These excerpts provide evidence to support the main claims made by the author. They emphasize the role of sugar and slavery in shaping history, particularly the rise of England and the exploitation of African slaves for economic gain.
By examining the author’s perspective, we can better understand the central claim of the passage and the evidence provided to support it. The author highlights the interconnectedness of sugar, slavery, and global power, shedding light on a dark chapter in history.
Critique And Counterarguments
In examining the author’s claim, it is essential to consider potential challenges and alternative viewpoints. By doing so, we can gain a more comprehensive understanding of the topic. Let’s explore some of the critiques and counterarguments that arise from the passage.
Challenges To The Author’s Claim
- The economic impact: One of the challenges to the author’s claim is the assumption that the English were getting richer solely because Africans were being enslaved. While it is true that sugar played a significant role in the English economy, other factors, such as industrialization and colonial expansion, also contributed to their economic growth. It is essential to acknowledge these additional elements to provide a complete perspective on the subject.
- Environmental and social consequences: Another critique is the focus solely on the economic benefits of the sugar industry, without addressing the adverse environmental and social consequences. The passage fails to mention the exploitation of workers, harsh living conditions, and degradation of the land. By examining these aspects, we can have a more nuanced understanding of the impact of the sugar trade.
Examination Of Alternative Viewpoints
To gain a more comprehensive understanding of the author’s claim, it is crucial to analyze alternative viewpoints. This enables us to consider diverse perspectives and their implications.
| Alternative Viewpoint |
|---|
| The increase in wealth was not solely due to the sugar trade, but also to the exploitation of other resources in colonial territories. |
| The economic growth of the English was not solely due to sugar, but also to advancements in industrialization and trade. |
| The impact of the sugar trade on enslaved Africans and its long-lasting consequences should also be considered when discussing the authors’ claim. |
By critically examining these alternative viewpoints, we can gain a more well-rounded understanding of the complex issues surrounding the authors’ claim. It allows us to question assumptions, consider multiple perspectives, and form a more independent analysis.
Final Thoughts On Sugar’s Legacy
The excerpt from the passage that best states the authors’ claim is: “The English were getting richer because Africans were being exploited and enslaved to produce sugar. ” This passage highlights the connection between the wealth of the English and the labor and suffering of Africans in the sugar industry.
Synthesis Of The Book’s Theme
The book “Sugar Changed the World” explores the profound impact that sugar has had throughout history, particularly in relation to the rise of the English empire. Through a captivating narrative, the authors highlight the intertwining stories of sugar, slavery, and colonization, shedding light on the global significance of this once-rare commodity. The central theme of the book revolves around the transformative power of sugar and the complex legacy it has left behind.Reflection On Sugar’s Contemporary Relevance
Despite its historical context, the book also prompts readers to consider the contemporary relevance of sugar. While advancements in agriculture and technology have made sugar more accessible than ever before, the lingering effects of its production and consumption cannot be ignored. From the prevalence of modern-day slavery in sugar-producing regions to the detrimental impact of excessive sugar consumption on public health, the book serves as a timely reminder of the enduring consequences of our sugary past. After delving into the pages of “Sugar Changed the World,” it becomes evident that the legacy of sugar stretches far beyond mere sweetness and satisfaction. The rise of the English empire, fueled by the profitability of sugar plantations, forever altered the course of history. The authors’ claim becomes evident in passages such as, “English factories, you might say, were built, run, and paid for by sugar,” which succinctly captures the economic impact of this commodity. This claim is further supported by the assertion that sugar “whitened the world,” alluding to its pervasive influence on global trade routes and cultural practices. As we navigate the complexities of the modern world, it is crucial to recognize and reckon with the multifaceted legacy of sugar. From the forced labor endured by enslaved Africans to the environmental repercussions of large-scale sugar cultivation, the consequences of our sweet cravings cannot be ignored. By acknowledging the intertwined histories of sugar and slavery, we can move towards a more equitable and sustainable future, one that prioritizes the welfare of individuals and the planet.
Credit: www.amazon.com
Frequently Asked Questions Of Which Excerpt From The Passage Best States The Authors Claim
Which Excerpt From The Passage Best States The Authors Claim From Sugar Changed The World?
“The English were getting richer because English factories, you might say, were built, run, and paid for by sugar. “
Which Excerpt From The Passage Best States The Authors Claim As A Weeder Your Job?
“The excerpt from the passage that best states the authors’ claim as a weeder your job is: ‘It was some of the worst labor. ‘ This excerpt highlights the difficult and challenging nature of the job of a weeder, supporting the author’s claim.
“
What Is The Author’s Overall Claim In The Passage?
“The English were getting richer because Africans were being exploited for their labor in the sugar industry. “
Which Excerpt Best States The Authors Claim For An African?
The excerpt that best states the author’s claim is: “For an African, whether you were sent to the Caribbean or South America, you were now part of the sugar machine. “
Conclusion
Based on the analysis of the provided excerpts, it can be inferred that the best statement that states the author’s claim is “English factories, you might say, were built, run, and paid for by sugar. ” This excerpt emphasizes the connection between sugar production and the economic prosperity of the English.
It highlights how the English were becoming richer due to their involvement in the sugar industry. This statement supports the author’s claim regarding the impact of sugar on the English economy.